Class shouldn't feel like American Idol auditions, where Simon Cowell crushes dreams with brutal honesty while Paula Abdul hands out meaningless compliments. 

Jette Crow, a visual arts teacher at Foothill High School, rejected grading methods that sort kids into "talented" vs. "hopeless" categories. With two decades of teaching mixed-age, mixed-ability classes, her five-category assessment system gives every student genuine paths to academic success.

Read on to borrow her five-category grading rubric that works across diverse subjects, learning needs, and skill levels.

Here’s what’s on the dashboard this week: 

  • Today’s Deep Dive: How to grade students without crushing their souls

  • Reading Rainbow: Paper ceilings, AI majors, and poetry therapy

  • From Our Desk: What does football have to do with education?

  • Watch of the Week: Radiation + lesson plans = nuclear learning

How to Grade Students Without Crushing Their Souls

When Jette Crow looks at her drawing and painting classes, she doesn't see winners and losers. 

She sees 200 students—aged 13 to 19—who deserve better than the typical art class sorting system that elevates natural talent while crushing everyone else's confidence.

Her solution: a five-category grading rubric that completely reimagines how teachers can evaluate creative work through a collaborative four-step process that actually builds student skills while maintaining real standards.

  • Step 1: Design the Five-Category Rubric


    Every assignment gets evaluated across five distinct areas: following directions (with specific measurable criteria), creativity, aesthetic value, craftsmanship, and completion progress. Students can excel in different categories using their unique strengths. So even if a student’s technical skill is low, they can still earn an A- or B+ by scoring high everywhere else in the rubric.

  • Step 2: Set Crystal-Clear Expectations

    Each project includes five specific, non-negotiable requirements that eliminate grading mystery. This way, students know exactly what success looks like before they pick up a brush or pencil.

  • Step 3: Require Student Self-Assessment

    Students complete the entire rubric themselves before a teacher should review anything. This is a mandatory step for teachers to implement. It's how students learn to evaluate their own work honestly and advocate for their learning process.

  • Step 4: Conduct 1:1 Assessment Conversations

    Using student self-evaluations as starting points, have brief face-to-face discussions about their work. Teachers like Jette will often find that students think they deserve a grade much higher than they think.

By implementing a fair assessment system, students across all skill levels find authentic paths to success. At the same time, they’re also developing communication abilities, math literacy, and self-advocacy skills that transfer far beyond the classroom. 

When grading becomes collaborative rather than punitive, something beautiful happens: kids stop fearing evaluation and start embracing it as a tool for growth.

Steal Jette's complete grading system here.

  • Geography Saves the Day for Sleepy Students: Place-based project learning is giving mid-year classroom energy the CPR it desperately needs. Turns out, kids get more excited about math when they're calculating how many tons of garbage their actual neighborhood produces versus solving word problems about fictional Train A and Train B.

  • Students Discover AI Majors, Parents Discover Panic: College kids are flooding into AI programs faster than they abandoned their promise to call mom every weekend. Computer science departments are scrambling to hire professors who actually understand machine learning, instead of those who can spell "algorithm."

  • Trauma Poetry Gets the Handbook It Deserves: "The Wounded Line" guide offers teachers a guide for helping students write poems about difficult experiences without turning creative writing class into group therapy. Note: "Dear diary, today I learned metaphors" counts as creative writing, not psychological intervention.

  • When Your Bachelor's Degree Becomes a Dead End: The job market's getting pickier about college degrees, and workers without them might hit what experts call a "paper ceiling"—even for jobs that don't actually require degree-level skills. In other words, college diplomas are now required to answer phones, which is like requiring a pilot's license to ride a bicycle.

  • On the Subject Podcast #67: CEO Mike Vilardo sat down with Tim Clary, our Partnerships Manager and former D1 football player, for a conversation that tackles everything from NIL money madness to transfer portal chaos. Clary also breaks down why good old-fashioned hard work still matters more than flashy contracts.

  • How Subject is using UDL
    We all know one-size-fits-all instruction is in the rear window. So we’re proactively solving for this with the Universal Design for Learning (UDL) framework. Our research-based curriculum responds to student and teacher needs, and we’re always looking for ways to personalize more and support all types of learning.

Our pick of the week: Fallout (Amazon)


Why We’re Obsessed: Season 2 is dropping weekly and the fan reactions are absolutely nuclear. The show's retro-futuristic aesthetic mixed with post-apocalyptic survival creates the perfect blend of nostalgia and anarchy that somehow makes radiation poisoning look cinematically gorgeous. Plus, it's one of the few video game adaptations that doesn't make fans want to crawl back into a vault and never emerge.

Recommended lesson integration:

  • Alternative History & "What If" Scenarios (Grades 9-12): Explore how small political decisions can lead to massive consequences, using the show's pre-war timeline as a case study in cause and effect. Kind of like how every “it’ll be fine” in history eventually leads to mushroom clouds and student essays.

  • Nuclear Science Meets Pop Culture (Grades 6-12): Teach actual radiation science through the show's creative liberties, comparing Hollywood mutations to real atomic physics. Time to finally explain why real radiation gives you tumors, not telekinesis—sorry, Marvel fans.

  • Economics of Scarcity (Grades 7-12): Use bottle caps as currency to demonstrate supply and demand, inflation, and bartering systems when traditional money becomes worthless. Inflation’s real lesson: at the end of the world, a Starbucks drink still costs $9.

  • Environmental Science and Human Impact (Grades 9-12): Discuss real-world nuclear accidents, cleanup efforts, and environmental recovery using the wasteland as an extreme example. Because who needs a field trip when the planet is the field trip?

  • Moral Philosophy and Survival Ethics (Grades 10-12): Debate tough choices about resource allocation, community leadership, and what "civilization" means when everything falls apart. Explore questions like: “Is democracy still a thing if everyone’s on fire?”


Thank you for joining us for another edition of On The Subject. We’ll see you again in a week, with more stories from the hallways.

The Subject Team

Want to learn more about our curriculum offerings? Contact us today.

Share On The Subject!

{{rp_personalized_text}}

{{rp_upcoming_milestones}}

Or copy and share this link: {{rp_refer_url}}

Keep Reading

No posts found